Blog

We keep you up-to-date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.

Luxury Second Home Surcharge: Impact on High-Value Estates

When the term “Taylor Swift tax” comes up, it might sound like a playful reference. However, this is not a celebrity homage but a serious discussion on housing policy reform.

The state of Rhode Island has introduced a surcharge on luxury second homes which could substantially affect non-primary residences. According to Realtor.com, properties exceeding $1 million in value could incur an additional tax of $2.50 per $500 of value over the million mark. For instance, a $2 million home would see an increase of $5,000 in annual property taxes. This policy takes effect in July 2026, with adjustments for inflation beginning in mid-2027. Crucially, properties rented out more than 183 days a year are exempt from this surcharge.

Image 1

The Origin of the "Taylor Swift Tax" Nickname

While unofficial, the moniker is gaining traction in media circles due to Taylor Swift's ownership of a luxurious estate in Watch Hill, Rhode Island. Her property, estimated at $17 million, could face an annual tax increase of $136,000 under this proposal. While partly whimsical, the name highlights a broader tax applied to all luxury homes.

High Watch, the mansion Swift owns, boasts a storied past. It was constructed between 1929 and 1930 for the Snowden family, who named it Holiday House. The estate passed to socialite Rebekah Harkness in 1948, renowned for extravagant gatherings. Businessman Gurdon B. Wattles later refurbished it, bestowing the name High Watch. Swift acquired the property in 2013, and it inspired her 2020 song "The Last Great American Dynasty".

Image 2

Legislative Perspectives on the Surcharge

The surcharge is backed by Senator Meghan Kallman, who argues it promotes fairness, allowing Rhode Island to secure essential funding without cutting services like healthcare and education. It's particularly targeted at out-of-state property owners contributing minimally to the local economy, creating a more equitable financial landscape.

Proponents see the law as a mechanism to:

  • Revitalize “lights-out” neighborhoods by encouraging property occupation

  • Finance affordable housing through the additional tax revenue

Nonetheless, critics caution that the tax could:

  • Hinder investment in high-value real estate

  • Depress property values or force long-time owners to sell

  • Unfairly affect families with longstanding ties to these homes

The digital discourse is lively, especially with public figures like Dave Portnoy chiming in. He humorously suggested Massachusetts could introduce a “Dave Portnoy tax” in his honor.

Future Directions and Considerations

Although not finalized, the surcharge gives homeowners until mid-2026 to comply by either:

  1. Proving residence for 183 days to avoid the surcharge, or

  2. Leasing the property to maintain activity

It’s a strategy aimed at reducing vacancy while boosting local revenue.

Image 3

Rhode Island isn't isolated in this endeavor. States like Montana and localities in California have similarly moved to adjust property taxes. From Montana's shift onto non-resident second-home owners to Los Angeles’s Measure ULA, which imposes a mansion tax on top-value property sales, these initiatives aim to address housing dynamics through financial policy. Further north, South Lake Tahoe considers a $6,000 tax initiative for long-vacant vacation homes, directly funding affordable housing projects.

While the "Taylor Swift tax" might evoke a grin, it addresses a tangible challenge—leveraging absentee wealth to stabilize communities. Coastal regions wrestling with housing affordability consider such initiatives crucial, even as they assess the balance between economic impact and popular appeal.

Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .